Skip to content

    Best-by dates versus signs that food has spoiled

    Best-by dates versus signs that food has spoiled

    You open the fridge and find a tub of yogurt with yesterday's date on it. Next to it is a container of cooked chicken you made last week. Which one should go?

    The date on a package is useful information, but it isn't the whole answer. How a food was stored, whether it has been opened, and how long it has been in the refrigerator all matter. And food can make you sick without looking or smelling spoiled.

    Here's a practical way to sort through the labels and the leftovers.

    What does “best if used by” mean?

    For most foods, a best-by date is the maker's estimate of when the product will have its best flavor or quality. It is not a magic switch that makes food unsafe at midnight. A box of crackers, for example, might eventually become stale rather than suddenly dangerous because the printed date passed.

    That doesn't mean every food past its date is safe. A date can't tell you whether a refrigerated item was left in a hot car, whether a package was damaged, or how it was handled after opening. Use the date along with the storage instructions and information you have about the food.

    You'll also see phrases like “sell by” and “use by.” They serve different purposes and can be confusing. Follow any specific handling instructions on the package, and check food-specific storage guidance when you aren't sure. Infant formula is an important exception: don't use it after its use-by date. Follow the date on baby food, too.

    A good smell isn't a safety test

    Visible mold, an unusual texture, or an off odor can be reasons to discard food. But the reverse isn't reliable: harmful germs may be present without an obvious change in smell, appearance, or taste.

    Don't taste something questionable to find out whether it's safe. A leftover that has sat too long or was left unrefrigerated can be unsafe even if it looks fine. If you don't know how long it has been there or how it was stored, the safer choice is to throw it out.

    Be particularly cautious with damaged cans and jars. A bulging or leaking container, a broken seal, or liquid spurting when a container is opened is a reason not to use the contents. Don't taste it. If you aren't sure how to handle a suspicious container, contact your local health department for guidance.

    The clock changes when food is opened or cooked

    The date printed on an unopened package doesn't necessarily tell you how long the food will keep once you've opened it. Follow the maker's after-opening directions where provided. For other foods, check guidance for that specific item.

    Cooked leftovers have their own timeline. Many can be kept in the refrigerator for three to four days when they've been handled safely. Refrigerate perishable leftovers within two hours, or within one hour if they've been exposed to temperatures above 90°F. Keep the refrigerator at 40°F or below.

    That chicken made last week is a different question from the unopened yogurt dated yesterday. Knowing when the chicken was cooked and refrigerated matters more than a date on the original package. If it has been in the refrigerator beyond the recommended window, discard it even if it smells normal.

    A simple labeling habit helps

    Write the food and date on a piece of tape when you put leftovers away. “Chicken, Monday” is enough to save a lot of guessing later. If you open a large container and won't remember when, add that date too.

    Put items you plan to eat soon where you can see them. If you know you won't finish a suitable leftover within its refrigerator window, freeze a portion promptly in a freezer-safe container and label it. Freezing can give you more time, but it doesn't make food that was already unsafe safe again.

    If you eat smaller portions than you used to, divide a fresh batch into portions before it becomes a week-long fridge experiment. Leave out only what you'll use and store the rest promptly. Follow the appropriate instructions for thawing and reheating the food later.

    What about a package that still has time left?

    A future date doesn't guarantee safety. Perishable food can become unsafe before that date if it was stored at the wrong temperature or left out too long. The same applies after a power outage or a long trip home from the store: what happened to the food matters.

    If a package's seal is broken when you buy it, bring it back or contact the store. For a recalled product, follow the recall instructions even if the date hasn't passed and nothing looks wrong.

    For people at higher risk from foodborne illness, including those who are pregnant, older adults, and people with weakened immune systems, careful food handling is especially important. Ask your healthcare team about any precautions that apply to you.

    When you're deciding what to keep

    Read the package, then ask: Has this been opened? Was it kept at the right temperature? How long ago was it cooked or refrigerated? Is the container intact? If an answer is missing, don't try to solve the puzzle with a taste test.

    The goal isn't to throw out food automatically when a quality date passes. It's to use the date as one clue and give storage and handling the attention they deserve.